The key facts

  • The vocalizations of more than 350 bird species were compared with human speech and singing in 52 languages
  • Shared patterns appeared in all groups of birds regardless of the ability to learn to sing
  • The work is published in the journal Science

Universal patterns of sound

A team of biologists at Canada's McGill University has identified patterns that unite birdsong and human speech across the world: small pitch intervals, even predictable rhythms, and a stretched-out final sound of a phrase. The results are published in the journal Science, reports Gazeta.Ru.

How the comparison was conducted

The study compared the vocalizations of more than 350 bird species: songbirds and hummingbirds, as well as closely related groups with innate rather than learned songs — suboscines and nightjars. The recordings were taken from the crowdsourcing site xeno-canto, where enthusiasts collect sounds of the wild, and about 70,000 vocal elements were manually annotated. The birds' trills were then compared with databases of human speech and singing in 52 languages — the patterns matched.

An unexpected result

The composition of the comparison participants is of particular interest. Songbirds, hummingbirds, and parrots are 'vocal learners': they acquire songs through imitation, just as a child acquires speech. Suboscines and nightjars sing 'by program,' from birth. Biologists expected the resemblance to humans to be more pronounced in the learner species, but the calculation did not hold up: the shared rules appeared equally in all groups, regardless of the ability to learn. The study is the first to compare birdsong with a global collection of human voices across both bird camps — 'learners' and 'born singers.'

A possible explanation

'We believe that the shared acoustic patterns in birds and humans may be explained by similar sound-production mechanisms or by features of sound perception,' said Logan James, the study's first author. 'For example, it is difficult for both birds and humans to change pitch sharply from note to note — hence the small intervals. And the stretching of the final sound is probably linked to breathing during singing and speech.' In the authors' view, the results help in the search for biological foundations of vocalization and hearing that are common to humans and animals. 'Given how similar to humans all these groups of birds are, we hope the work will encourage colleagues to study birds that have long been overlooked — those that do not learn to sing,' noted the senior author, Professor Jon Sakata.