The key facts

  • About a quarter of children understand some form of deception by ten months — University of Bristol study
  • Around a quarter of children understand some form of deception by ten months — University of Bristol research
  • By the age of three, children become noticeably more skilled at lying and begin to withhold information
  • The psychologist advises creating a safe environment so the child can admit a mistake
  • The psychologist advises creating a safe environment so a child can admit a mistake

Lying as a developmental stage

Drawings on the wall and missing biscuits are grounds to blame the dog or a 'ghost', even if the child is holding the crayons and covered in crumbs. This is exactly the situation with which the BBC News piece on children's deception begins: according to clinical psychologist Dr Jade Redfern, speaking on the podcast CBeebies Parenting Download, lying is 'a skill they develop and play with in order to get better at it'.

Deception begins before the age of one

Young children are not yet 'sophisticated' enough to lie, but they are capable of deception before their first birthday, says Redfern. One of the studies mentioned in the podcast was conducted by the University of Bristol: according to its findings, about a quarter of children understand some form of deception by ten months. Professor Elena Hoicka, who led the work, noted how 'remarkably early' children show cunning — including her own: 'As a mother of three, I can confirm how skilled and crafty they are. Hiding under the table or in the bathroom to eat sweets or chocolate is their favourite trick'.

From simple deception to 'theory of mind'

According to Hoicka, two-year-olds' deception is fairly primitive: the child pretends not to hear the parent or denies what they have done; this also includes forbidden activities done in secret — for example, peeking into a bag they were not allowed to look into, or excuses like 'I need the toilet' when asked to tidy up. By the age of three, children are far better at deception and begin to withhold information: for instance, they truthfully report that a sibling hit them, but leave out that they hit first. Redfern links this to the development of 'theory of mind' — the understanding that other people have their own thoughts and intentions; empathy, she says, is built on this too. Another reason for lying is self-preservation: the child is afraid of upsetting or disappointing a parent they depend on.

How to encourage honesty

Since children are 'driven by attachment' — their bond with a caregiver — Redfern advises creating an environment in which it is safe for the child to admit a mistake. Rachel Duffy, winner of the most recent season of The Traitors, a mother of three, told the podcast how this works in practice: her eldest son took his brother's bike, wrecked it by crashing into a car, and at first tried to lie. 'I told him: “You won't be in big trouble if you tell the truth.” I simply walked away and gave him a bit of space. And he said: “Yes, it was me.” He realised that this space was safe. We talked — no shouting.' Redfern calls this a good example and adds that sometimes lying or leaving things out is appropriate — for example, when a child receives an unwanted gift or describes other people's appearance. Her own children recently 'delightedly' informed her that she is 'very wrinkly'; instead of taking offence, she suggests an open, curious conversation — in her view, this is precisely how children gradually develop empathy.

Child seated at a flour-covered table in the foreground, holding a piece of cookie dough to their mouth. Rolled-out dough covers the table, with shaped biscuits, metal cookie cutters and a baking tray visible nearby. Additional dough pieces and baking equipment are spread across the work surface, while a sofa and children's books can be seen in the background.Image source, Elena Hoicka
Image caption,

Prof Hoicka's daughter Ada tries to sneakily eat cookie dough aged two when she thought her mum wasn't looking

Child kneeling on a wooden floor beneath a table in the foreground, holding a marshmallow to their mouth. An open pink-and-white bag labelled marshmallows rests beside their knees. Wooden cupboards form the background, and a chair and table leg are visible nearby.Image source, Elena Hoicka
Image caption,

Prof Hoicka's daughter Juno also deceives her aged three by hiding under a table to eat marshmallows

A child stands barefoot in a bathroom in the foreground, holding a piece of chocolate in one hand. Chocolate is smeared around the mouth and on one hand. A toilet with the seat raised is directly behind the child, with a toilet roll holder, radiator and washing machine visible nearby. The room has a wooden floor and light-coloured walls.Image source, Elena Hoicka
Image caption,

Ada, age two, deceives her mum by hiding in the bathroom to eat chocolate she had stolen

An adult sits on a blanket on grass in the foreground, holding a child on their lap while another child sits on their shoulders. The group is outdoors beside a hedge and trees. One child wears a floral dress and cardigan, while the other wears a patterned sleeveless outfit and green shoes. The blanket is spread on a lawn with dense greenery forming the background.Image source, Elena Hoicka
Image caption,

Prof Hoicka with her daughters Ada, now aged six, and Juno who is three years old

A mother and teenage daughter sit facing one another on a sofa in a lounge. The daughter is holding her hands up and animatedly talking to her mother as if she is trying to get a point across. Her mother is sitting still with her arms folded in her lap with a blank expression as if she doesn't understand her daughter.A little girl wearing a rainbow dress looks down at a daisy chain in her hand. Her mother is crouching down next to her, talking to her.A child stands in a garden in the foreground, holding a hose spray nozzle above their head and watering raised wooden planters. Water arcs from the nozzle across the planters, which contain various flowers and leafy plants. A wooden bird-table-style structure stands beside the planters. A wooden fence and dense hedging form the background.