The key facts

  • 11 EU countries sent a note ahead of the culture ministers' meeting calling on the European Commission to present a legislative proposal 'as soon as possible'
  • In May, a similar appeal was signed by 8 countries — the initiative is gaining support
  • Under its work programme, the Commission plans a digitalisation and copyright package for the second quarter of 2027

Eleven countries demand a legislative response

Germany, Spain, Poland, Austria, Cyprus, Croatia, Denmark, Estonia, Portugal, Slovakia and Slovenia sent a note for the agenda of the EU culture ministers' meeting, urging the European Commission to 'present an appropriate legislative proposal as soon as possible'. The goal is to protect the cultural and creative sector from the practices of AI developers, who train models on data collected from the open internet, often without regard to whether the material is protected by copyright.

The essence of the dispute and the parties' positions

In the document, the countries emphasise that with AI's transition from pure research to broad practical application, 'profound upheavals' have occurred in creative processes and the perception of art, and the need for action is becoming increasingly urgent. The stated goal is 'to protect human creative work while ensuring AI innovation in Europe', with a demand for fair competition with non-European providers regardless of where the model was trained. For the technology sector, restricting access to protected content would mean falling behind the US and China in the AI race; for the creative industries, current practice amounts to mass theft that undermines livelihoods. The split also runs within governments: economics ministries usually support startups, while culture ministries back authors.

What has been done and what comes next

The initiative is a continuation of May's appeal by eight countries — the number of supporters is growing. Earlier this month, the European Commission closed a public consultation on possible measures to strengthen copyright protection, including the use of protected content in AI. Under its work programme, the Commission is due to present a legislative package on digital transformation, simplification and copyright in the second quarter of 2027 — that is, noticeably later than the signatories demand. The EU already has a Copyright Directive in force that allows authors to opt out of the use of their works for AI development; the countries are asking that this opt-out mechanism be made simpler for practical use on an accelerated timeline.