The key facts

  • Vote on lifting the ban on Brazilian chicken postponed: several EU countries have requested clarifications from the European Commission
  • The ban on Brazilian meat (beef, poultry, eggs, honey) has been in effect since September due to antimicrobial growth promoters
  • An EU audit in early September found Brazil's poultry farming control system effective; new discussion in early December

Vote postponed

EU member states on Tuesday postponed a vote on lifting the ban on imports of Brazilian poultry, after several countries asked the European Commission to provide further clarification on how well Brazil complies with EU rules on antimicrobial substances. This was reported by Euronews, citing Commission spokesperson Eva Hrnčířová: 'A number of member states have requested further clarification on the system established by Brazil.' According to her, the Commission 'will take time to consider these remarks and questions' before a new meeting in early December.

The essence of the ban and the contradiction with the audit

The ban on imports of Brazilian meat was introduced in September due to Brazil's use of antimicrobial substances to stimulate animal growth. It covers beef, poultry, eggs and honey, and followed a vote by national experts in May. At the same time, an EU audit conducted in early September found that Brazil's poultry farming control system works effectively — and it is precisely against the backdrop of this finding that the decision on lifting the restrictions is being postponed.

Context of the Mercosur agreement

The ban caused discontent in Brazil, as it came into force just a few months after the controversial EU trade agreement with the Mercosur countries (Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay) provisionally entered into force, opening up trade in agricultural products, including Brazilian meat. The agreement was signed in January this year, but its ratification is delayed: the European Parliament has referred the treaty to the Court of Justice of the EU to verify its legality, and in May the Commission, under pressure from the Mercosur countries and states supporting the deal, primarily Spain and Germany, decided to apply the agreement provisionally until the judges' decision.

Divisions within the EU and quotas

Imports of Brazilian meat remain a contentious issue within the European Union itself: several countries, led by France, are strongly opposed to the Mercosur agreement. European farmers fear dumping due to lower production standards in the signatory countries, especially in the area of veterinary and phytosanitary rules. To address their concerns, the agreement includes quotas for duty-free access to sensitive agricultural products: beef imports are limited to 99,000 tonnes per year at a reduced tariff of 7.5% (about 1.5% of EU production), and poultry to 180,000 tonnes per year, or 1.3% of the European volume.