The key facts

  • Berset rejected the notion of a “migration crisis” and of the right to asylum being politically untenable
  • He questioned whether “return centres” outside the EU are compatible with European human rights standards
  • Five EU countries announced the Rwanda partnership on Monday

Berset against pitting migration control against human rights

Council of Europe Secretary General Alain Berset said in an interview with Euronews that European governments have the right to tighten migration policy, but must not undermine their human rights obligations. “Human rights are human rights for everyone, or for no one”, the outlet quotes him as saying. Berset rejected suggestions that Europe is facing a migration crisis or that the right to asylum is becoming politically untenable: in his view, governments are capable of combining stricter immigration controls with international obligations.

Deportations and “return centres”

Berset stressed that European human rights law does not prevent governments from deporting migrants who have no legal right to stay: the European Court of Human Rights, he said, has in some cases found removals lawful and in others ruled against them. At the same time, he questioned whether plans to create so-called return centres outside the European Union are compatible with European human rights standards.

Statement amid the Rwanda agreement

The comment came on the day when five EU countries announced a partnership with Rwanda to create a return centre for people whose asylum applications have been rejected. Berset expressed regret that the preparations apparently went ahead without continuing the discussions begun earlier in the Council of Europe. He warned that respect for the rules-based order, which he called necessary for stability, peace and predictability, must also underpin Europe's approach to migration.