The key facts

  • The U.S. Justice Department voluntarily withdrew its lawsuit over 20,000 ballots in California after courts refused its demands
  • Reason for withdrawal: the ballots were mixed with the rest before the November 13 hearing, making the demand unenforceable
  • The department says it will continue seeking review of California's voter rolls in a separate case

Lawsuit withdrawn after all courts refused

The U.S. Department of Justice on Friday filed a motion for the voluntary dismissal of its lawsuit, which had demanded that California and Los Angeles County officials remove about 20,000 ballots, allegedly cast by non-citizens, from the count, Anadolu reports. Earlier, District Judge David Carter and a Ninth Circuit appellate panel rejected this demand, and the Supreme Court declined to hear the administration's appeal without noted opinions.

Why the case was dropped

In the dismissal motion, U.S. Assistant Attorney General Julie Hamill stated that the requested measure had become impossible: the midterm elections ended on Tuesday, and the contested ballots would be mixed with lawful ones before the November 13 hearing. 'After that, there is no way to separate the contested ballots,' she wrote; according to her, 'the relief sought and required by the United States is no longer available,' which is what makes the dismissal necessary.

The parties' positions

Justice Department spokesperson Kirsten Pels called the case moot but emphasized that the administration 'is not backing down' on its work regarding alleged voting by non-citizens, including in a separate case in which the department demands that California conduct voter list maintenance. Thus, the withdrawal of the lawsuit is explained precisely by the impossibility of fulfilling the demand after the election, not by an abandonment of the department's overall course.

Reaction in California

Judge Carter had already ruled on October 28 that the demand was likely unconstitutional, since elections fall under the states' purview, and called the government's claims 'unworthy of credence.' Los Angeles County Registrar Dean Logan said he was 'glad the administration accepted the clarity of the courts' conclusions,' while California Attorney General Rob Bonta stated that the administration 'has abandoned its last unlawful attempt to interfere in California's elections and disenfranchise eligible voters.'