England's courts receive new rules for urgent newborn cases

What the new rules change

New guidance has been issued to judges in England and Wales restricting the practice of urgent hearings in cases involving newborns. A hearing on the day an application is filed must now be scheduled only when, without court intervention, the child's immediate safety is at risk; such applications are expected to be 'extremely rare'. For urgent and short-notice hearings within five days, applicants must justify the need for such a timescale with evidence, and if the judge does not consider the level of urgency sufficient, the case will receive a standard listing on days 12–18. This was reported by BBC News citing guidance published by the Judiciary.

The scale of the problem identified before the changes

The changes followed data showing a high proportion of urgent cases. According to the BBC, more than half of urgent care proceedings hearings in England in 2024–25 concerned newborns, and mothers had to appear in court within days of giving birth, sometimes on the very same day. Research by the Nuffield Family Justice Observatory showed that more than 70% of care proceedings involving infants in England were urgent hearings within two days of the application being filed, and the proportion of newborns whose cases were heard on the day of filing doubled over a decade — from one in ten in 2012–13 to one in five in 2022–23. In October, the BBC also reported, drawing on research from the universities of Lancaster and Oxford, that the number of children involved in care proceedings before their first birthday remains consistently high across England; experts interviewed by the File on 4 Investigates programme feared that some infants may have been taken into care and permanently separated from their families unnecessarily, since younger children are more often placed for adoption.

Protocol for newborns and support for families

Alongside the guidance, a protocol on newborn cases has been published, aimed at achieving 'a higher level of justice' for the child and parents when care proceedings are initiated immediately after birth. In England, it provides for early referral and assessment by local children's services to ensure timely provision of preventive support, including identifying and strengthening the family network's resources where this serves the child's interests. Before any application for a care order is filed, parents must be offered a family decision-making meeting in accordance with the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026. Emma Smale, Head of Practice and Policy at the Nuffield Family Justice Observatory, called the new guidance an 'encouraging attention' to the problem, noting that the separation of a mother from her infant immediately after birth 'is widely recognised as deeply traumatic for all involved', and questioning the fairness of 'deeply life-changing decisions' when a parent cannot participate effectively in the process. The Judiciary said the guidance is intended to help parents and carers 'prepare their response to an application more effectively' and to focus urgent intervention on cases that genuinely require it.

Image source, Getty Images