The key facts

  • The French Foreign Ministry called return centres ineffective and contrary to Paris's values
  • France ensured that the centres would not be funded from the EU budget
  • Five EU countries are exploring a centre with Rwanda; transfers of rejected asylum seekers are planned from 2027

Paris's position

The French Foreign Ministry said on Wednesday that the country will not take part in the proposed migrant return centres outside the European Union. The ministry's official spokesperson confirmed that Paris's position 'has not changed', responding to a question about statements by Minister-Delegate Benjamin Haddad regarding migrant camps in Rwanda. According to the spokesperson, 'in practice, these centres are ineffective in the way they are organised', and they 'do not reflect the values that we seek to defend'. At the same time, the spokesperson noted that European countries may take part in such projects using national funds, and that France ensured the centres would not receive funding from the EU budget.

The five-country project and the UK precedent

Paris's decision contrasts with the step taken by five other EU countries: Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands announced on Monday that they are exploring the creation of a return centre jointly with Rwanda and aim to reach an agreement and begin transferring rejected asylum seekers by 2027. According to a statement published by Denmark's immigration ministry, the centre will accept people who have no legal right to remain in the participating EU countries and who are subject to enforceable return orders. Those transferred will be able to integrate into Rwandan society or voluntarily leave for their countries of origin or other countries where they have the right to reside. The UK's experience shows the risks of such schemes: London previously agreed with Rwanda to send asylum seekers there, but the UK Supreme Court in November 2023 ruled the plan unlawful, finding substantial grounds to believe that deficiencies in the Rwandan asylum system create a 'real risk of refoulement' — the return of people to countries where they face persecution.