The key facts

  • The ban was approved by the President of the Court on 13 November following the Chamber's review
  • The documents featured non-existent cases and fabricated paragraphs of genuine judgments
  • The lawyer admitted using AI tools and described the errors as

ECtHR decision

The European Court of Human Rights has barred a Romanian lawyer from representing and assisting applicants before the Court for two years — the court's registry announced on Wednesday, Anadolu reports. The ban was approved by the President of the Court on 13 November after a Chamber found that documents submitted by the lawyer cited non-existent cases, while genuine judgments were attributed fabricated paragraph numbers. Some of the cited rulings were irrelevant or directly contradicted the arguments they were supposed to support.

Acknowledgement of AI use and the Chamber's findings

The lawyer admitted that she had used AI tools when preparing the documents and described the errors as

What the Chamber considered necessary

In the Chamber's view, the lawyer should have verified the AI-generated citations and arguments against authoritative sources, including the Court's own case-law database HUDOC, before submitting the documents. As for some of the citations, the Chamber noted,