The key facts

  • The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill will ban most new leasehold flats in England and Wales
  • Ground rent is to be capped at £250 a year, dropping to a symbolic 'peppercorn' after 40 years
  • The freeholders' association estimates potential investment losses at £18.7bn; the question of compensation remains unresolved

What is proposed to change

The UK government is preparing a bill that will ban the construction of most new leasehold flats in England and Wales. It is to be replaced by the commonhold system, under which residents collectively own and manage the building — a model already standard in Australia, New Zealand, the USA, Canada and most of continental Europe. Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook called the current system 'an anachronism in the twenty-first century' that 'poisons lives'. The reform follows Labour's 2024 election manifesto, which promised to 'end the feudal system of leasehold'; details were promised later.

What changes for existing leasehold owners

In addition to the ban on new flats, the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill provides for capping ground rent — the annual payment to the landowner — at £250, which after 40 years will fall to a symbolic 'peppercorn' level, effectively zero. According to the government, the document will also make it easier to convert existing buildings to commonhold, abolish the forfeiture mechanism under which a person can lose their home over small debts, increase transparency of service charges and limit estate charges. Pennycook said the reform would give existing leasehold owners 'more rights and protections' and 'simple and effective routes out'.

Contradictions and unresolved questions

Freeholders criticise the reform: the Residential Freehold Association, representing the largest landowners, said that '£18.7bn of investment could be instantly wiped out', calling the policy unfair and harmful to investment markets. Campaigners broadly welcome the reform but point to the main problem: converting already existing buildings to commonhold is significantly harder, and millions of current leasehold owners may be left behind. Giles Grover of the End Our Cladding Scandal campaign, which began work after the Grenfell Tower tragedy, warns of the risk of a 'two-tier system' for buyers of new and old housing. Questions of how existing owners will move to commonhold and whether freeholders will receive compensation remain unresolved.

Why the system is criticised

The essence of the problem is illustrated by the story of Fozia Malik from Oldham: her ground rent will rise from £150 to £300 in January, and service charges exceed £4,000 a year against the backdrop of fire safety problems. The managing company links the high charges to uncontrolled costs and expensive insurance due to fire safety issues. Malik, who grew up in Pakistan, expected that buying a flat also meant a share in the land, as in most countries of the world — but in England most flats are sold on leasehold terms: the buyer receives the right of use for a term, while the building and land remain the property of the freeholder. Over two years, more than 1,000 leasehold owners have contacted the BBC with complaints about the system; Malik herself describes living in such a flat as 'a continuous torture chamber' and says she would never buy leasehold property again.

Housing and apartments alongside the canal in the city centre of BirminghamImage source, Getty Images
Fozia Malik wears a headscarf, navy blouse and chunky necklace, and leans against a tree, smiling at the cameraImage source, Fozia Malik
Image caption,

Fozia Malik says she would

Selfie of Giles Grover, who has short greying hair and beard and black-rimmed glassesImage source, Giles Grover
Image caption,

Giles Grover, from the campaign group End Our Cladding Scandal, says there is a risk the proposed changes will create a two-tier system

A block of blue flats in Manchester, England pictured against a bright blue sky.A treated image of a modern apartment building with glass-fronted balconies.