The key facts

  • The US asked Ukraine whether it is ready to cede the Donetsk region in exchange for security guarantees; no concrete proposal has been presented yet
  • Zelensky stressed that he cannot decide the issue single-handedly and ruled out recognizing the occupation of territories
  • KIIS poll: 61% of Ukrainians categorically oppose withdrawing troops from the controlled part of Donbas even in exchange for guarantees

The essence of the US request

The United States asked Ukraine whether it is ready to hand the Donetsk region over to Russia in exchange for NATO membership or security guarantees. The Donetsk and Luhansk regions together make up Donbas: Russia controls almost all of Luhansk region and a significant part of Donetsk region, but Ukraine holds a number of major cities, including Kramatorsk and Sloviansk. According to President Volodymyr Zelensky, no concrete proposal has been put on the table yet: he said he would discuss the issue publicly once the US and NATO countries agree on a plan, and stressed that he cannot make such a decision 'single-handedly.' Any possible agreement, in his words, would be concluded 'without recognizing Russia's occupation of these territories.'

What guarantees are being discussed

Zelensky said the discussion concerns guarantees similar to those enshrined in Articles 4 and 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty — consultations in case of threats and the principle of 'an attack on one is an attack on all' — but without stationing American troops on Ukrainian territory. On the US side, the idea of bilateral guarantees modeled on agreements with Israel and a number of Middle Eastern countries was also voiced. Russia has not yet commented on these proposals: Vladimir Putin's press secretary Dmitry Peskov said that 'in the interests of the peace process, it is inappropriate to disclose details of negotiations with the Americans.'

Experts' skepticism and 'Budapest Memorandum 2.0'

Ukrainian experts interviewed by DW view the idea of trading territory for guarantees skeptically. Oleksandr Kraiev of the Ukrainian analytical center Ukrainian Prism believes that the US is incapable of single-handedly ensuring the fulfillment of such an agreement, and that at least half of NATO countries have reservations about Ukraine's accession. 'We would simply get a second Budapest Memorandum, just under a different name,' he said, recalling that the 1994 memorandum obliged Russia, the US and the UK to respect Ukraine's independence and borders in exchange for its renunciation of nuclear weapons, but contained no obligation to defend it in the event of an attack. Oleksandr Khara of the Centre for Defence Strategies added that ceding territory would violate Ukraine's constitution and undermine the world order 'in which borders cannot be redrawn by force,' and that any referendum on such a question would set a 'very dangerous precedent' — regardless of how citizens vote.

Public opinion and alternatives

A poll by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology, conducted October 8–16, showed that 61% of respondents categorically reject withdrawing troops from the parts of Donbas controlled by Ukraine, including Kramatorsk and Sloviansk, even in exchange for US and European guarantees; 35% said they would reluctantly accept such a deal. Khara doubts that a bilateral agreement with the US would give Kyiv more support than it has now: in his words, this means financial aid, joint weapons production and troop training — everything that is 'below the threshold of collective security,' although he considers a written fixation of commitments for at least five years a plus. Ideally, he believes, Ukraine needs 'nuclear shields' — a strategic one from the US and a tactical one from Europe. Serhii Solodkyi of the New Europe research center recalled an alternative scheme that Ukrainian experts proposed to the allies back in December 2023: NATO membership within internationally recognized borders, with protocols under which only territories under Kyiv's control are defended — modeled on West Germany, which joined the alliance before German reunification. 'West Germany never gave up on reunification. That means we should not give up our territory or recognize the border either,' he said, calling the proposed exchange 'a trap into which Russia and the American negotiators are trying to lure the Ukrainian side.'