The key facts

  • COP31 is taking place in Antalya; the conference will end on Friday
  • UNU-EHS expert Soenke Kreft: countries are 'entrenching their positions'; no progress toward consensus yet
  • The first draft of the final decision — 18 pages — is considered too long; contentious topics: climate finance, electrification, adaptation, the opinion of the International Court of Justice

Talks are ongoing, but no consensus yet

At the UN COP31 climate conference currently underway in Antalya, Turkey, delegations are not yet converging on key issues. This is how Soenke Kreft, a senior expert at the United Nations University Institute for Environment and Human Security (UNU-EHS) in Bonn, who is taking part in the negotiations, assessed the course of the talks. 'I think we are not yet at the stage where countries are genuinely moving toward consensus — rather, they are building up, or more precisely, entrenching their positions. But I think that is normal for this stage,' he said on the sidelines of the conference.

The draft final decision is too long

According to Kreft, negotiations went 'not badly' on Tuesday, but the recently published first draft of the final 'cover' decision is, from a textual standpoint, 'too long.' 'In the end, it is supposed to send a signal, and in 18 pages that cannot be done... It definitely needs to be shortened. But at the same time, of course, everyone has their own specific issues,' the expert noted. He stressed that greater progress is needed in the remaining days: the conference began last week and will end on Friday, and at previous COPs the main disputes traditionally unfolded precisely in the final days.

The main points of disagreement

Kreft listed potentially contentious items on the agenda: the volume and content of the final decision, sectoral guidance, the proposed electrification goal, the approach to a temporary overshoot of temperature limits, climate finance, possible new processes under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, and the question of whether to reference the advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on climate. On the topic of electrification, he noted that a number of countries oppose singling out individual technologies or sectors.

Dispute over the baseline for tripling adaptation finance

There are also disagreements over the goal of tripling adaptation finance. 'The differences, for example, lie in what constitutes the baseline for the tripling goal? Triple from what indicator?' Kreft explained. According to him, one option is either to agree on a specific figure or, if that is not possible, to at least launch a process that would provide more clarity on the adaptation finance goal.