The key facts

  • The Paris trial will run from June 17, 2027, with a preliminary hearing on February 25, 2027
  • The case concerns 24 iPhone models, from the iPhone XS to the 15 series and the 2022 iPhone SE
  • The possible fine is up to €300,000 plus up to 5% of the company's annual revenue

First repair-obstruction case sent to trial

Apple will appear before a Paris court in June 2027 on charges of 'obstructing the repair and refurbishment' of iPhones outside the company's authorized service network. According to a source familiar with the case, cited by AFP, this is the first case of its kind to reach trial. The complaint was filed back in December 2022 by the French association Halte à l'obsolescence programmée (HOP), which fights against planned obsolescence of devices. A preliminary hearing to set the trial schedule is scheduled for February 25, 2027, with the hearings themselves lasting four days starting June 17. In the dock are Apple Distribution International and the parent company Apple Inc. Apple itself told AFP: 'We firmly contest these unfounded accusations.'

The essence of the charges: component 'serialization'

At the center of the case is the practice of 'serialization,' in which the serial numbers of a device's components — the screen, battery, camera — are tied to the phone itself. HOP argues that this can cause malfunctions when parts are replaced by repairers outside Apple's authorized network, even if original spare parts are used without the company's software approval. According to the prosecution, specific consequences for users include Face ID being disabled when the camera is replaced by an unauthorized repair shop and the battery status display function ceasing to work. The charges cover the period from November 2021 to July 2024 and 24 iPhone models — from the iPhone XS and the 12, 13, 14 and 15 series to the 2022 iPhone SE. In the association's view, the aim of the practice was to boost sales of the flagship product and increase the company's revenue, which exceeds $400 billion a year, roughly half of which comes from iPhone sales.

Possible sanctions and previous cases

If found guilty, Apple faces a fine of up to €300,000 plus an additional fine of up to 5% of annual revenue — according to euronews' calculations at the time of publication, roughly €21.7 billion — as well as compensation claims from customers. The association notes that since 2022 Apple has announced measures to limit serialization in new iPhones and to allow certain repairs to be validated by third parties, but in HOP's view the effectiveness of these changes remains to be proven over time. This is not the first case against the company initiated by HOP: in February 2021, Apple agreed to pay €25 million for failing to inform users that software updates were slowing down older devices. That settlement was one of several worldwide following Apple's admission in December 2017 that its iOS slows down older phones with degrading batteries.