The key facts
- From April to September, 43,000 disputes were filed concerning Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube and other platforms; more than 19,000 were deemed eligible for review
- About 75% of platform decisions were overturned: YouTube — 93%, TikTok — 77%, Instagram — 75%
- Complaints included AI-generated investment and romance scams, as well as misleading videos about the Russia-Ukraine war and the 2024 Valencia flood
Platforms fail to remove scam content after complaints
Major social networks fail to remove fraudulent content even after user complaints: the independent European appeals body overturns the majority of the moderation decisions it has examined. This was reported by Irish broadcaster RTE, citing data from the organisation Appeals Centre Europe.
Scale of disputes and share of overturned decisions
From April to September, Appeals Centre Europe received 43,000 disputes concerning Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube and other platforms; more than 19,000 of them were deemed eligible for review. The organisation found that platforms left fraudulent content online in violation of their own rules, and that AI-generated material makes scams increasingly hard to recognise. Of the decisions reviewed, the body overturned about 75%, including 93% of YouTube decisions, 77% of TikTok decisions and 75% of Instagram decisions.
What complaints were filed and the status of decisions
Among the reported cases were AI-generated investment and romance scams, as well as misleading videos about the Russia-Ukraine war and the 2024 flood in Valencia. Appeals Centre Europe chief executive Thomas Hughes said social platforms must not provide shelter for fraudsters. The organisation is based in Dublin and handles content moderation disputes under the EU Digital Services Act. Its decisions are not binding, but platforms are required to engage with it in good faith.

