The key facts

  • The ECtHR ordered Turkey to release Can Atalay and allow him to take his seat in parliament
  • The court awarded €32,500 in compensation and linked the case to the detention of opponents, human rights defenders and journalists
  • Atalay was elected in 2023 from Silivri prison; Turkey's Constitutional Court had previously also ruled in his favour

The ECtHR ruling in the Atalay case

The European Court of Human Rights has published its ruling in the case of Can Atalay — a human rights lawyer and elected member of the Turkish parliament who remains in detention. As Deutsche Welle reports, the court ruled that Turkey must release Atalay and allow him to take his parliamentary seat. The judges concluded that his continued detention aimed to silence him and undermine political pluralism. Turkey has also been ordered to pay Atalay €32,500 (about $35,700) in compensation.

The case in its broader context

The judges particularly stressed that Atalay's case should not be viewed in isolation — but rather in the broader context of the detention of political opponents, human rights defenders and journalists in Turkey. Deutsche Welle recalls that Turkey was among the original signatories of the European Convention on Human Rights, yet it has previously refused to comply with ECtHR rulings in the cases of human rights defender Osman Kavala and prominent Kurdish politician Selahattin Demirtaş. This lends the new ruling a largely advisory character: whether it is enforced depends on Ankara's position, and there are already precedents of non-compliance.

From lawyer to imprisoned deputy

As a lawyer, Atalay represented victims in numerous public and political cases in Turkey, including freedom-of-speech cases involving journalists and writers. He was also one of the prominent voices of the 2013 Gezi Park protests, which the authorities called an attempted coup. In April 2022, Atalay, along with seven other defendants, was sentenced to 18 years in prison for 'aiding an attempted coup' over his participation in the protests.

A mandate won from prison

Continuing his fight from the notorious Silivri prison, Atalay ran for the Workers' Party of Turkey (TİP) in the 2023 parliamentary elections. He was a candidate in the earthquake-affected province of Hatay and won a mandate, but was not released despite repeated rulings by the Constitutional Court — the country's highest judicial authority. In 2024, his parliamentary status was revoked; the Constitutional Court later overturned that decision, but President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's party did not allow the opposition to formally read out the verdict in parliament. A year later, one of the opposition deputies did read out the ruling, yet Atalay remained in detention. After the ECtHR verdict was published, TİP leader Erkan Baş called on social media for Atalay's release and the restoration of his parliamentary mandate.