The key facts
- Judge Ana Reyes temporarily barred the closure of East Potomac Golf Links until November 28
- Trump announced a 15-month reconstruction, calling the course 'Trash Island'
- The judge questioned the candor of Justice Department lawyers and opened a separate review involving a special master
Decision on the Eve of the Closure
Federal judge Ana Reyes of the U.S. District Court on Saturday, November 15, temporarily blocked the Trump administration's plans to close the historic public golf course East Potomac Golf Links in Washington. The president had announced that the 106-year-old course, located about 3 km south of the White House, would be closed from November 15 for 15 months for a large-scale reconstruction. The judge ruled that the park and the course must remain open, but noted that the administration is not obligated to actively manage them. Her order is in effect until November 28.
The Court's Arguments
In her 30-page ruling, Reyes wrote that the justifications for the closure proposed by the administration are pretextual, and that the government violated at least two federal laws 'for the sake of an arbitrary deadline.' 'The government proposes to close a historic park, visited daily by Washington residents of all walks of life, for an indefinite period,' the judge stated. In her view, the closure contradicts the public interest in the use of national parks, and the government failed to show any harm from maintaining the status quo. Reyes also rejected the Justice Department's claim that the November 15 closure was necessary for safety reasons, and ruled that the closure would cause 'irreparable harm' to the plaintiffs — individual golfers and historic preservation advocates.
Background of the Dispute and the Parties' Positions
The legal dispute began in February, when the DC Preservation League and others filed a lawsuit against the reconstruction plans. The conflict escalated in October, when the National Park Service began cutting down hundreds of trees, having notified the judge only 15 hours before the work started; after that, Reyes ordered a halt to the tree cutting until October 26. Trump, an avid golfer, called the current course 'Trash Island' and promised to create 'one of the best and most spectacular golf courses in the world,' open to the public and capable of hosting world-class tournaments. Separately, the judge opened a review into whether Justice Department lawyers had misled the court and violated ethical rules; the review will proceed with the participation of a special master. The Justice Department unsuccessfully sought Reyes's recusal from the case, and after the ruling said it would continue to vigorously defend the administration's policy: according to its spokesperson, the court recognized the National Park Service's authority to restrict access when there is a safety threat, and the ruling does not prevent planning for a world-class course.
Image source, EPA 



