The key facts

  • The Ninth Circuit voted 6-5 to reinstate the earlier overturned order on Election Day
  • The administration may demand that ballots of suspected non-citizens be set aside and warn of federal prosecution
  • Five judges dissented; Chief Judge Murguia called the warnings pressure on election commissions

Court restores powers on Election Day

On Tuesday, November 3, the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled 6-5 to reinstate an earlier order that removed restrictions on the Trump administration's efforts to pressure state election authorities into setting aside ballots of voters suspected of not being US citizens. According to Anadolu, the ruling allows the administration to resume the relevant requests and warnings about possible federal prosecution.

Three rulings in 12 hours

The order became the court's third ruling in roughly 12 hours — a series of legal twists unfolded right on Election Day. First, a three-judge panel stayed a district court decision that had limited the administration's actions. Then the full Ninth Circuit overturned that ruling and ordered reconsideration by the full court (en banc). Finally, on Tuesday, an 11-judge panel voted 6-5 to reinstate the stay once again, restoring the administration's ability to act.

What the administration is now allowed to do

Under the ruling now in effect, the administration may continue asking state election officials to set aside ballots connected with individuals suspected of not being citizens and of lacking the right to vote. Federal officials may also warn election authorities that knowingly counting unlawful ballots could lead to federal prosecution. In addition, the stayed order relieves the administration of the duty to disclose certain pending warrants and grand jury subpoenas concerning individuals allegedly ineligible to vote, and of the duty to notify election officials about the district judge's restrictions.

Judges' positions and the minority's dissent

Judges Eric D. Miller and Mark J. Bennett, in separate opinions, acknowledged that the Justice Department's interpretations of the law may be unfounded, but noted that courts generally cannot bar the department from communicating its interpretation of federal criminal law, even if it is wrong. Five judges dissented, expressing concern about the consequences for election officials and voters. Chief Judge Mary Murguia, according to Anadolu, said that the warnings of federal prosecution place election officials in an untenable position, forcing them to navigate between conflicting legal obligations while conducting elections.