The key facts

  • Derbyshire police admitted the unlawful entry into the Firn couple's home in December 2022 and settled the claim for £9,000
  • The couple's charges of assaulting police officers were dropped during the trial after the unlawfulness of the entry was acknowledged
  • The police apologised but said no disciplinary measures were taken against the officers, and rejected a number of the couple's individual claims

Admission of unlawful actions and payout

Andrew and Sabrina Firn, a married couple from the Alveston area of Derby, will receive £9,000 under a settlement of a civil claim against Derbyshire police, which admitted that its officers acted outside their powers in December 2022, unlawfully entered their home and used force. This was reported by BBC News, citing the Local Democracy Reporting Service.

Timeline of the incident

According to the account set out in the claim documents, the couple's house party had ended when they discovered that one of the guests had a knife. Sabrina called the police; officers arrived and soon left. Several officers then returned, believing that someone inside the house needed urgent medical attention. Sabrina, 31, refused to let the police in because the guests had already left, but was unable to prevent the entry: officers broke down the door and used physical force against her. Andrew, 40, intervened out of concern for his wife, and, according to the documents, 'excessive force' was also used against him.

The trial and the civil claim

Both spouses were arrested and charged with assaulting an emergency services worker. However, midway through the trial, the police presented evidence that the entry into the home had been unlawful, and the couple were acquitted — according to their lawyers, this happened at Southern Derbyshire Magistrates' Court in December 2023. After the acquittal, the couple filed a civil claim for unlawful entry, Andrew's unlawful arrest and the use of force against both of them, which the police accepted; the case was settled for £9,000.

The police's position and disagreements over details

In a statement, Derbyshire police apologised for the distress caused, explaining that the officers had acted on the 'genuine belief' that someone inside the house might have been harmed, but subsequently admitted that, because of the time that had elapsed between the initial call and the entry, the grounds under Section 17 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act (PACE) had not been met, so the entry and all subsequent actions were unlawful. At the same time, the police rejected a number of individual claims: it did not admit that Sabrina's arrest was unlawful, arguing that she was not handcuffed and was not detained, and that an arrest was unnecessary given the medical episode during which officers provided first aid; the claims about Andrew's dislocated shoulder, malicious persecution and officer negligence were also not accepted. No disciplinary measures were taken against the officers, the police added.

The couple's reaction

Sabrina Firn said the incident caused enormous stress and left her with severe post-traumatic stress disorder: 'I was terrified. I have terrible PTSD. If I had unlawfully entered someone's home and harmed people, I would have been prosecuted for assault. I would have a criminal record. Not one of these police officers has been held accountable for what they did.' The disagreement between the parties persists even after the settlement: the police admitted the entry was unlawful but disputes individual circumstances of the arrest and the use of force, while the couple, in their words, see no accountability for the individual officers.

Doorbell footage of police officers with their faces blurredImage source, Supplied
Image caption,

Derbyshire Police admitted its officers went outside their powers and acted unlawfully in December 2022