The key facts

  • Boris Pistorius called criticism of Ukrainian strikes 'stupid' and described strikes on military targets in Russia as lawful
  • Elbridge Colby reportedly believed that strikes on Russian civilian infrastructure strengthen Russia's resolve to escalate
  • The dispute came after the first Russia-Ukraine talks since February, mediated by the US in the UAE

Pistorius pushed back against Washington

Germany has publicly diverged from the United States in its assessment of Ukraine's long-range strikes into Russian territory. According to Anadolu, at a press briefing in Brussels German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius, when asked whether he shared the position of US Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby that such strikes should no longer be carried out, said: criticizing strikes on strategic military targets and facilities used for military purposes in Russia is a 'rather stupid thing.'

'This is a kind of terrorism'

Pistorius added that instead of criticizing Ukrainian strikes, it would be worth discussing the 'terrorist strikes every night and every day' against Ukraine's civilian energy, water and heating infrastructure, calling them terrorism, while describing Kyiv's strikes on non-commercial (non-civilian) targets in Russia as lawful and legitimate. Colby, according to reports, argued that Ukrainian long-range strikes on Russia's civilian infrastructure could, on the contrary, strengthen the resolve of Russian society and the Kremlin's readiness to escalate.

Context of the dispute

Both sides of the conflict deny deliberately striking civilian infrastructure, insisting that their targets are only military or military-related facilities. The positions were voiced after Russia-Ukraine talks mediated by the United States concluded last week in the UAE — the first since February; their notable outcome was plans for a large-scale prisoner exchange. Pistorius's statement shows that even among Kyiv's allies there is no unity on the question of whether strikes deep into Russian territory are acceptable.