The key facts

  • Judge Jeannette Vargas rejected the motion by two FIFA American units to block UEFA's evidence gathering
  • UEFA may request documents from JP Morgan and Joshua Kushner's Thrive Capital under the FFE plan
  • Infantino intends to run for re-election; candidate applications are accepted until November 18

Court allows UEFA to continue gathering evidence

Federal judge Jeannette Vargas of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York on Thursday rejected a motion by FIFA's American units, which had sought to block UEFA's evidence-gathering efforts related to FIFA president Gianni Infantino's attempts to sell stakes in the World Cup and other tournaments to private investors. UEFA filed a discovery request in August with the aim of removing Infantino from office and stated that if signs of financial misconduct were found, it would file a criminal complaint against him in Switzerland.

What this means in practice

The court ruling allows UEFA to seek the right to obtain documents on the deal from the American bank JP Morgan and the investment firm Thrive Capital, owned by Joshua Kushner — brother of Jared Kushner, the son-in-law of US President Donald Trump, and son of US Ambassador to France Charles Kushner. The matter concerns the so-called FIFA Forward Enterprise (FFE) project, which provoked a fierce negative reaction as soon as it became known in July.

The parties' arguments

Two FIFA units sought the block, but Vargas ruled that they had no 'direct, substantial and legally protectable interest' in the case, which is directed specifically against Infantino and his actions. According to her, 'nothing in the case materials indicates that FIFA's American structures or even FIFA itself will be parties in the criminal proceedings under consideration,' and they 'have not presented facts suggesting that they would be defendants.' FIFA's lawyers objected that 'the court did not consider the substance of UEFA's motion and the documents are not yet required to be provided.'

Context of the FFE plan and the confrontation

Infantino faced harsh criticism for his attempt to create the FFE to manage FIFA's commercial interests in the World Cup and other tournaments with the sale of minority stakes to private investors. Three continental confederations rejected the plan, and UEFA threatened a boycott of future FIFA tournaments if it were not scrapped. Each of the 211 national federations, which effectively own the Zurich-based non-profit organization, was offered $20 million for approving the project. Infantino initially resisted, but in August was forced to abandon the plan. UEFA has since continued to seek his removal and demands answers, in particular, on how Thrive was chosen to lead the group of investors. In September, FIFA told a judge in Florida, where the organization has an office in a Miami suburb, that UEFA's legal actions amounted to a persecution of Infantino. This is the biggest challenge in his 11 years at the head of FIFA.

The fight for the presidency

Infantino shows no signs of readiness to step down and plans to run for re-election, for which he must pass an eligibility and integrity review conducted by a commission appointed by FIFA. The only person to have declared candidacy so far is the Japanese Kozo Tashima, a member of FIFA's 37-member ruling council since 2016. UEFA, according to reports, expects to put forward another candidate and is seeking to have Arsene Wenger — head of FIFA's global development division and former coach of London's Arsenal, who is nevertheless Infantino's subordinate — run against the incumbent president. Those wishing to challenge the post must declare themselves by Wednesday, November 18.