The key facts

  • The mother, Halima El Bakhti (72), was sentenced to 20 years; the father, Ahmed Tolub (74), to 15 years as an accomplice
  • Four-year-old Inass Tolub was found on 11 August 1987 near the A10 motorway; her identity was established only in 2018 through her brother's DNA
  • The jury found that the mother had diminished capacity to understand her actions at the time of the child's death, which reduced the maximum sentence; the parties have 10 days to appeal

A verdict nearly four decades later

The assize court of the Loir-et-Cher department delivered its verdict in the case of the death of four-year-old Inass Tolub, whose body was found on 11 August 1987 near the A10 motorway close to the commune of Suevres in central France. The girl's mother, 72-year-old Halima El Bakhti, was found guilty on Tuesday of 'torture and acts of barbarity resulting in death without intent to kill' and sentenced to 20 years in prison. The father, 74-year-old Ahmed Tolub, was sentenced to 15 years as an accomplice.

'The little martyr of the A10'

The child's body bore numerous signs of violence: human bite marks, fractures, and burns from an iron. The girl was buried in an unmarked grave not far from where the body was found. For nearly three decades she remained unidentified and was known only as 'the little martyr of the A10.' Her identity was established in 2018: the DNA of her brother, taken in connection with an entirely different case, matched her DNA, which led to the parents' arrest.

The trial and the verdict

The trial at the Loir-et-Cher assize court began on 2 November; the verdict was delivered on Tuesday after several hours of jury deliberation. Prosecutor Anaïs Allio stressed during the trial that 'no part of Inass's body was spared,' and recalled 'the dizziness that gripped all of us' upon seeing the 'unbearable photographs' from the autopsy. The jury concluded that the mother suffered from a diminished capacity to understand her actions at the moment of the child's death — this reduced the maximum possible sentence. According to France Info, both defendants sat stoically with their heads bowed while the reasoning behind the verdict was read out. El Bakhti and Tolub have 10 days to appeal.

One of France's largest investigations

The girl's death triggered one of the largest investigations in French history: her photograph was displayed in public places, and an alert was sent to more than 30 countries. Despite this, the case remained unsolved for more than 30 years — until the accidental DNA identification in 2018.

Court sketch shows the parents of Inass Touloub, Halima El Bakhti and Ahmed Touloub, during their trialImage source, Getty Images
The grave of Inass Touloub in the communal cemetery of SuèvresImage source, Getty Images